MONITORING OF CASES OF INEFFICIENT (IRRATIONAL, NON-TARGETED) USE OF FUNDS BY THE COMMUNITIES OF THE LUGHAN REGION DURING WAR IN 2022-2023

Keywords: fund utilization, criteria, efficiency, expediency, communities, Luhansk region, monitoring, rationality

Abstract

The article discusses the methodological principles for monitoring the effec-tiveness (rationality, expediency) of fund utilization by communities. This is based on analyzing the expenditure of budget funds by these communities, con-sidering factors such as the amount spent, alignment with the community's objec-tives (expediency of use), price competitiveness, contractor suitability, and alignment with the scale of community activities, among others. Criteria for inefficiency (ineffectiveness, inappropriate use) of funds by communities were identified. These include dubiousness of the tender, lack of ur-gent need for procurement during the war, lack of justified need for purchase, in-consistency of the quantitative and financial procurement parameters of the scale of the community's activities, inflated price, non-market prices, failure to take into account analogues of goods and services, a critical number of participants in state tenders, presence of discriminatory requirements in the tender, anti-competitive actions of customers and contractors, lack of feasibility of purchase, price non-competitiveness, non-competitiveness of the performer, non-critical costs. The article presents the results of monitoring 31 cases of inefficient (irra-tional, inappropriate) fund use by communities in the Luhansk region during the war in 2022-2023. The total amount of procurement by the communities of the Luhansk region during the war in 2022 amounted to UAH 42,625,830, in 2023 – UAH 5,764,926. The main procurements that are recognized as inefficient, inexpedient and irrational are significant purchases of heavy construction equipment, computer equipment, significant costs for office equipment and supplies, and other pur-chases that require justification of their expediency. Monitoring the effectiveness (rationality, expediency) of fund utilization by communities during wartime is crucial for effective budget management. It en-hances transparency, ensures an optimal balance between costs and outcomes, and provides recommendations for the future use of community funds.

References

Громадська спілка "Інститут народного аудиту". URL: https://www.ina.org.ua/

Рух "Чесно". URL: https://www.chesno.org/post/1009/

Громадський проєкт "Народний аудит". URL: https://www.clean-europe.com/audyt/index.php

Prozorro URL: https://prozorro.gov.ua/uk

Аналітичний хаб Qlik. URL: https://bi.prozorro.org/hub

Методика здійснення порівняльного аналізу ефективності бюджетних програм, які виконуються розпорядниками коштів місцевих бюджетів. Лист Міністерства фінансів України від 19.09.2013 р № 31-05110-14-5/27486. https://www.ibser.org.ua/sites/default/files/metodyka_zdiysnennya_porivnyalnogo_analizu.pdf

Заблодська І.В., Сєрєбряк К.І., Татарченко О.М. Вплив інфраструк-тури Луганської області на якість життя населення: оцінка та рекомендації. Економіка та право. 2021, № 4. С. 68–78. DOI:https://doi.org/10.15407/econlaw. 2021.04.068

Як викрити корупцію в медичних закупівлях. Міністерство цифрової трансформації. URL: https://www.instagram.com/p/C29XfPBNbhs/?hl=ru

Прозорість та підзвітність у державному управлінні та послугах/ TAPAS та Prozorro. URL: https://www.instagram.com/p/C29XfPBNbhs/?hl=ru

Hromadska spilka "Instytut narodnoho audytu". [Public union "Institute of People's Audit"]. URL: https://www.ina.org.ua/ (data zvernennia: 27.03.2024)

Rukh "Chesno" ["Chesno" movement]. Available at: https://www.chesno.org/post/1009/ (data zvernennia: 20.03.2024)

Громадський проєкт "Народний аудит". [Public union "Institute of People's Audit"]. Available at: https://www.clean-europe.com/audyt/index.php (data zvernennia: 25.03.2024)

Prozorro Available at: https://prozorro.gov.ua/uk (data zvernennia: 2.03.2024)

Analitychnyi khab Qlik [Qlik analytical hub]. Available at: https://bi.prozorro.org/hub (data zvernennia: 2.03.2024)

Metodyka zdiisnennia porivnialnoho analizu efektyvnosti biudzhet-nykh prohram, yaki vykonuiutsia rozporiadnykamy koshtiv mistsevykh biudzhetiv. Lyst Ministerstva finansiv Ukrainy vid 19.09.2013 r № 31-05110-14-5/27486 [Methodology for conducting a comparative analysis of the effectiveness of budg-et programs implemented by managers of local budget funds. Letter of the Minis-try of Finance of Ukraine dated September 19, 2013 No. 31-05110-14-5/27486]. Available at: https://www.ibser.org.ua/sites/default/files/metodyka_zdiysnennya_porivnyalnogo_analizu.pdf (data zvernennia: 18.03.2024)

Zablodska I.V., Sieriebriak K.I., Tatarchenko O.M. (2021) Vplyv infra-struktury Luhanskoi oblasti na yakist zhyttia naselennia: otsinka ta rekomendatsii [Zablodska I.V., Serebryak K.I., Tatarchenko O.M. The impact of the infrastruc-ture of Luhansk region on the quality of life of the population: assessment and rec-ommendations] Ekonomika ta pravo. № 4. pp. 68–78. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/econlaw. 2021.04.068 (data zvernennia: 20.03.2024)

Yak vykryty koruptsiiu v medychnykh zakupivliakh. Ministerstvo tsyfrovoi transformatsii [How to expose corruption in medical procurement. Min-istry of Digital Transformation] Available at: https://www.instagram.com/p/C29XfPBNbhs/?hl=ru (data zvernennia: 2.04.2024)

Prozorist ta pidzvitnist u derzhavnomu upravlinni ta posluhakh / TAPAS та Prozorro [Transparency and accountability in public administration and ser-vices] Available at: https://www.instagram.com/p/C29XfPBNbhs/?hl=ru (data zvernennia: 14.03.2024)

Article views: 64
PDF Downloads: 75
Published
2024-03-26
How to Cite
Vartanova , O., Buzko, I., & Burbelo , S. (2024). MONITORING OF CASES OF INEFFICIENT (IRRATIONAL, NON-TARGETED) USE OF FUNDS BY THE COMMUNITIES OF THE LUGHAN REGION DURING WAR IN 2022-2023. Economy and Society, (61). https://doi.org/10.32782/2524-0072/2024-61-1
Section
ECONOMICS